15,255
pages
ALL POSTSWhat happened to Ming-Hua's arms?
<p>Clearly we know that Ming-Hua has to use a psychic bending technique due to the absence of arms, but what happened? Did she lose her arms during the kidnapping attempt 13 years ago? Or does anyone have another possible theory?
</p>
(Edited by administrators)
<div class="quote"><i>
<p>Neo Bahamut wrote:
</p>
<div class="quote">
<p>KyoshiWarriors wrote:
Where can I find the Q & A?
</p>
</i></div>
<p>You could do what I do whenever I need to find it again & Google "Avatar Wiki Q&A Mike & Bryan." </p> <div class="quote"><i>Use of legs isn't a novel thing in waterbending. Don't recall if Ming-Hua ever used them, but regular waterbenders certainly have.</i></div>
<p>Honestly, the only waterbending moves I'm familiar with that use the legs are one in the <i>Legend of Korra</i> game & the waterspout, though I don't doubt that it's possible. </p> </div> <p>In ATLA, Katara used them a couple times. Once when she grounded herself with ice on her feet in her duel with Paku, and her large water whip when they stormed the Earth Kingdom Royal Palace. Dunno if her and Aang's few "surfing" moves count as feet use. In Korra, I think we've seen a few feet uses in pro-bending. </p>
<p>You could do what I do whenever I need to find it again & Google "Avatar Wiki Q&A Mike & Bryan." </p> <div class="quote"><i>Use of legs isn't a novel thing in waterbending. Don't recall if Ming-Hua ever used them, but regular waterbenders certainly have.</i></div>
<p>Honestly, the only waterbending moves I'm familiar with that use the legs are one in the <i>Legend of Korra</i> game & the waterspout, though I don't doubt that it's possible. </p> </div> <p>In ATLA, Katara used them a couple times. Once when she grounded herself with ice on her feet in her duel with Paku, and her large water whip when they stormed the Earth Kingdom Royal Palace. Dunno if her and Aang's few "surfing" moves count as feet use. In Korra, I think we've seen a few feet uses in pro-bending. </p>
(Edited by Omnibender)
She used a water whip with her feet?
(Edited by Neo Bahamut)
<div class="quote"><i>
<p>Neo Bahamut wrote:
She used a water whip with her feet?
</p>
</i></div>
<p>She uses water from her skin to create an ice ramp/arc at the edge of a river with her hands, slides it up into the air, and then draws water from the river with her leg, making a very long water whip, way longer than she is tall, spins around pushing loads of guards into the river, and lands doing a cartwheel. She then does a regular whip with her arms to take out some guards at the top of some stairs above her. Aang then freezes the river to trap the guards. </p>
<p>She uses water from her skin to create an ice ramp/arc at the edge of a river with her hands, slides it up into the air, and then draws water from the river with her leg, making a very long water whip, way longer than she is tall, spins around pushing loads of guards into the river, and lands doing a cartwheel. She then does a regular whip with her arms to take out some guards at the top of some stairs above her. Aang then freezes the river to trap the guards. </p>
(Edited by Omnibender)
<p>I'll have to rewatch this scene when I get the chance, that sounds like an interesting maneuver.
</p>
(Edited by Neo Bahamut)
<div class="quote"><i>
<p>Neo Bahamut wrote:
I'll have to rewatch this scene when I get the chance, that sounds like an interesting maneuver.
</p>
</i></div>
<p>Not the same as video, but the screenshots should give you an idea. </p>
<p>Not the same as video, but the screenshots should give you an idea. </p>
(Edited by Omnibender)
<p>The video is pretty easy to find, but thanks.
</p>
(Edited by Neo Bahamut)
<div class="quote"><i>Omnibender wrote:
That I think it's just her opinion. No mention of spine or shoulder blades either in her article, or the waterbending article.</i></div>
<p>There was some video or another in which Bryke talked about choreographing Ming-Hua's moves, and they mentioned leg work. Her use of her spine and shoulderblades is based on personal observation; for example, when getting her water whips back in "Rebirth," she does an exaggeratedly dynamic spin and shimmies her upper body. </p>
That I think it's just her opinion. No mention of spine or shoulder blades either in her article, or the waterbending article.</i></div>
<p>There was some video or another in which Bryke talked about choreographing Ming-Hua's moves, and they mentioned leg work. Her use of her spine and shoulderblades is based on personal observation; for example, when getting her water whips back in "Rebirth," she does an exaggeratedly dynamic spin and shimmies her upper body. </p>
(Edited by Deist Zealot)
<div class="quote"><i>XXTaiWolfXx wrote:
<div class="quote"> <p>-Darjeeling- wrote: Why psychic bending? Firebenders, earthbenders and airbenders are able to bend with their feet. Right now, I can't recall a situation where waterbenders used their feet because that's not their style, but I don't think it's impossible. So we shouldn't call it psychic bending. </p> </i></div>
<p>Fair point, Darjeeling. In fact, watching the scene where P'Li was rescued in "Harm's Way" again, it looks like Ming-Hua is using her feet to aid her in battle. It almost looks like she incorporated earthbending techniques into her waterbending, but that's probably inaccurate. </p> </div> <p>It actually states that the Red Lotus members devolped a vagabond style of bending, incorperating all types of different techniques. </p>
<div class="quote"> <p>-Darjeeling- wrote: Why psychic bending? Firebenders, earthbenders and airbenders are able to bend with their feet. Right now, I can't recall a situation where waterbenders used their feet because that's not their style, but I don't think it's impossible. So we shouldn't call it psychic bending. </p> </i></div>
<p>Fair point, Darjeeling. In fact, watching the scene where P'Li was rescued in "Harm's Way" again, it looks like Ming-Hua is using her feet to aid her in battle. It almost looks like she incorporated earthbending techniques into her waterbending, but that's probably inaccurate. </p> </div> <p>It actually states that the Red Lotus members devolped a vagabond style of bending, incorperating all types of different techniques. </p>
(Edited by Fledgeling the SkyWing)
<div class="quote"><i>Fledgeling the SkyWing wrote:
It actually states that the Red Lotus members devolped a vagabond style of bending, incorperating all types of different techniques. </i></div>
<p>Yep. <s>Which means that she <i>totally</i> sparred with Ghazan on a regular basis before 158AG; just saying.</s>
</p>
It actually states that the Red Lotus members devolped a vagabond style of bending, incorperating all types of different techniques. </i></div>
<p>Yep. <s>Which means that she <i>totally</i> sparred with Ghazan on a regular basis before 158AG; just saying.</s>
</p>
(Edited by Deist Zealot)
<p>It's mentioned in the art book as well that she was born without arms; there's a picture of the Red Lotus members when they were younger, and the notes clarify that it isn't canon, since Ming-hua has arms in the picture.
</p>
(Edited by Katrinasforest)