15,254
pages
ALL POSTSColors
<p>Each element has colors associated with it. Water=blue/white, fire=red/orange/black, earth=green, air=orange/yellow. water and fire make sense: water is blue and snow/ice is white; fire is red/orange, and ash (result of fire) is black. but why is earth green and air orange/yellow? nothing about earth is green, unless you count certain jemstones (although bendable, not very common) and air is certaintly not orange or yellow. earth should be black or brown, the common color of dirt/rocks. air would be blue/white (color of clouds and the sky) but those colors are already taken by water (so what do you think air should be?) what do you think about this?
</p>
(Edited by administrators)
Should we end the thread now?
(Edited by ShortswitsoxZ)
Air Nation is more white/grey symbol
(Edited by KevinTriforce)
<div class="quote"><i>KevinTriforce wrote:
Air Nation is more white/grey symbol</i></div>
<p>Wr are refuring to clothing. </p>
Air Nation is more white/grey symbol</i></div>
<p>Wr are refuring to clothing. </p>
(Edited by ShortswitsoxZ)
<p>Earth is always green. It was not the creators ideas.I also never understood the oran=ge/yellow thing either but i think the thing about the seasons makes sense.
</p>
(Edited by MysticNerd)
<div class="quote"><i>MysticNerd wrote:
Earth is always green. It was not the creators ideas.I also never understood the oran=ge/yellow thing either but i think the thing about the seasons makes sense.</i></div>
<p>Tell that to the ancient chinese, which represented earth as yellow. Or pretty much any non-european culture. </p>
Earth is always green. It was not the creators ideas.I also never understood the oran=ge/yellow thing either but i think the thing about the seasons makes sense.</i></div>
<p>Tell that to the ancient chinese, which represented earth as yellow. Or pretty much any non-european culture. </p>
(Edited by Falconfly)
<p>The thing is "earth" doesn't only refer to dirt (usually brown or orange/reddish), the earth also has connotations with growth, health, and nature which is green. Brown isn't a great color for symbolism.... just because its a neutral (so is gray). I would assume that yellow/orange indicates happiness, although we should probably mention that yellow *is* the color of hope.
</p>
(Edited by Winterfirstsnow*)
<div class="quote"><i>Winterfirstsnow* wrote:
The thing is "earth" doesn't only refer to dirt (usually brown or orange/reddish), the earth also has connotations with growth, health, and nature which is green. Brown isn't a great color for symbolism.... just because its a neutral (so is gray). I would assume that yellow/orange indicates happiness, although we should probably mention that yellow *is* the color of hope.</i></div>
<p>Those are western associations for earth. The ancient chinese, for instance, saw vegetation as a different element, more intricately associated with air and wind. To them, earth was the quintessence, the primal element from which all others sprang form, which is why yellow, their colour of majesty and honour, is often said to be "where yin and yang sprang forth from". And they viewed it as actual earth, as dirt and rocks. </p><p>
</p><p>Same in Avatar. Earthbenders can't bend wood or generate vegetation. Remember, modern western associations are not universal. White in China is the color of death, black the one of neutrality. </p>
The thing is "earth" doesn't only refer to dirt (usually brown or orange/reddish), the earth also has connotations with growth, health, and nature which is green. Brown isn't a great color for symbolism.... just because its a neutral (so is gray). I would assume that yellow/orange indicates happiness, although we should probably mention that yellow *is* the color of hope.</i></div>
<p>Those are western associations for earth. The ancient chinese, for instance, saw vegetation as a different element, more intricately associated with air and wind. To them, earth was the quintessence, the primal element from which all others sprang form, which is why yellow, their colour of majesty and honour, is often said to be "where yin and yang sprang forth from". And they viewed it as actual earth, as dirt and rocks. </p><p>
</p><p>Same in Avatar. Earthbenders can't bend wood or generate vegetation. Remember, modern western associations are not universal. White in China is the color of death, black the one of neutrality. </p>
(Edited by Falconfly)
<p>^ I get that, but clearly Bryke was not influenced by Chinese culture when designing the nations' color schemes. Its not exactly surprising that two Westerners used western symbolism. I doubt that there is any connection between Chinese (or other east Asian) culture and the colors of ATLA, so I offered what I know about color symbolism. Frankly, the ancient Chinese connotations, while interesting, are completely off topic.
</p>
(Edited by Winterfirstsnow*)
<p>Still, they went to great lengths to avoid connecting earth to plants, and the earth element as a whole in the Avatar verse is more associated with order/structure than nourishing, so...
</p>
(Edited by Falconfly)
<div class="quote"><i>Falconfly wrote:
Still, they went to great lengths to avoid connecting earth to plants, and the earth element as a whole in the Avatar verse is more associated with order/structure than nourishing, so...</i></div>
<p>It is worldly connected to stability. </p>
Still, they went to great lengths to avoid connecting earth to plants, and the earth element as a whole in the Avatar verse is more associated with order/structure than nourishing, so...</i></div>
<p>It is worldly connected to stability. </p>
(Edited by MysticNerd)